Communications staff in House Member offices have an average of two years of experience on the Hill. Through the first half of this year, that same job turned over at 42.4 percent — the highest rate of any role in the building.
Two years in, and two years out.
That's a staffing statistic. It isn't a staffing problem.
It's the reason constituent outreach programs stall in the same place over and over. Everything that makes one work — who's on which list, why they're on it, what's reached them before and what hasn't — lives in one person's head. That person is on a two-year clock. The limit on the program isn't what the office knows how to do. It's how long anyone stays to do it.
Which makes it a question about what the office owns, not about who it hires. Part of a communications program belongs to whoever is in the chair. Part of it belongs to the office. Most offices have never drawn that line, and the program pays for it every couple of years.
Nobody in This Story Did Anything Wrong.
Moving every couple of years is how the Hill works. It's how pay and title advance, most chiefs of staff did it themselves at the same age, and it isn't a failure of loyalty on anyone's part. Some of that 42 percent is people moving up rather than leaving Congress, which is the system working the way it's supposed to.
The program doesn't know the difference.
More Communications Staff, Less Communications Experience.
Offices have taken this work seriously. One analysis of House staffing found communications roles grew by roughly 45 percent between 2016 and 2025, even as most offices got smaller — from 16 or 17 staff through 2018 to 15 or 16 after.
So the work grew inside a shrinking office, and it grew by hiring young. Every communications job in a Member office — staff, deputy, director — ranks among both the least experienced and the highest-turnover positions in the House, and nearly a third of communications staff hold a second role alongside the press job.
The headcount is real. The experience isn't. And because the whole shop turns over on roughly the same clock, there's usually nobody left who has seen the same idea tried twice.
The Program Takes Longer to Build Than the Job Lasts.
A good constituent outreach program isn't something you launch. It's something that compounds.
You figure out who your constituents actually are and what they care about. You reach them where they are. You watch what lands and what doesn't. You fix the groups that aren't responding and keep the ones that are. The program in month thirty is far better than the program in month six, and the difference isn't talent. It's everything that happened in between.
That arc is longer than the job. The office builds something, it starts to work, and the person who understood why it worked leaves before the program catches up. Then the clock restarts, and the program never gets past its own learning phase — not because anyone failed, but because nobody is there long enough to finish.
A Transition Memo Tells You What. It Can't Tell You Why.
This happens even when the handoff is handled well. It usually goes something like this.
The communications director gives three weeks' notice and writes a careful transition memo. Every audience the office has built, the calendar, the logins, the vendor contacts. Her replacement starts a month later, reads it closely, and understands the structure completely.
What the memo can't tell him is why the agriculture list was built the way it was, or which two versions of it failed first, or what happened the one time the office sent everything to everyone. He inherits a structure and has to rebuild the reasoning underneath it. That takes months, sometimes years, and the office isn't standing still while he does it.
Nobody wants to be the person who sent the wrong thing to the wrong people. So the safe choice is the message that needs no explanation: one send to everybody. The audiences stay in the system and go unused. The program goes back to being a blast without anyone deciding that it should.
And it shows up in the numbers. Opens fall. Clicks fall. Constituents who used to read because the message was about them start skipping it, because it isn't anymore. Over time that erodes the sender reputation underneath the whole program, so even the messages that would have landed stop landing. The office is still sending and still paying for it. Fewer constituents are hearing from it than a year ago.
Look at what the memo did contain. The calendar, the logins, the vendor contacts — everything that was easy to write down. The office had documented the parts that didn't need explaining and left the rest with the person who was leaving.
You lose ground before you start making it back.
Good Ideas Are Not the Shortage.
Hire the twenty-two-year-old. The ideas are worth having, so is the energy, and an office that only hires veterans goes stale in a different way.
What two years on the job can't give you is someone who has watched an idea fail before. The person who can say we tried that in 2023, and here's why it didn't land. Or: that's the right instinct, wrong format. Or: that won't clear franking review the way you've written it. And separately, someone who can do the technical work without learning it first — rebuilding how a list is split up, fixing what broke on the website, changing who sees an ad. Those take real practice, and the office pays for it again every time that seat turns over.
New ideas are abundant on the Hill, and they arrive with every new hire. Knowing which ones have already been tried is the part that has to be kept somewhere.
The Budget Isn't Going to Solve This.
The obvious answer is to pay the communications team more and bring in someone senior. It's the right instinct, and it runs straight into the MRA.
House staffing fell again this year against flat office budgets — down about one percent between February and March alone, the second-largest drop across the second sessions of the last five Congresses. New offices run roughly 1.8 staff smaller than established ones, a gap that has shown up in every first session since 2017.
A chief of staff can't conjure a senior communications hire out of an MRA that isn't growing. Whatever the answer is, it isn't more money.
Decide What the Office Owns Before the First Hire, Not After the First Departure.
Start with the free part, which almost every office skips. Write down why the lists exist, not just what they are. Who each one was built for, what you tried before it, what didn't work, what happened when you sent. Putting that together after the fact is a few days of real work; keeping it current from the start costs almost nothing. It's the difference between a successor inheriting a program and a successor inheriting a spreadsheet.
Then look at who owns what. The writing, the pitching, the judgment about what the district wants to hear this month — that belongs to the staffer, and it should. The structure underneath the program is an office asset. Most offices have those filed backwards. They document the calendar and leave the reasoning in one person's head, which means the newest person on the team is the only one who knows why the program works. That isn't a staffing arrangement. It's a single point of failure with a two-year fuse.
Your Vendor Will Outlast Your Communications Director. Choose Accordingly.
Run the arithmetic on a decade. An office will go through three or four communications directors, probably more at the staff level. It can keep the same firm for all ten years. Most offices have that backwards in their heads — staff feel permanent and vendors feel swappable — and it is the other way around.
Which means the vendor is where the continuity actually sits, whether anyone planned it that way or not. That is worth being deliberate about, because it changes what an office should be shopping for.
Not a shop that buys your ads and knows nothing else about the program. Not one that designs your postcards and has never seen your list. A narrow vendor executes a piece of the work and leaves the thinking where it was — in the head of the staffer who is leaving in two years. What an office needs is someone working across the whole operation: who's on which list and why, what's reached them, what to try next, and where a new tool genuinely helps versus where it's an expensive distraction.
It also usually means a smaller firm rather than a bigger one. A large agency assigns an account manager, and the people who know your district are three layers down from the people you talk to. A smaller firm puts you with the person actually doing the work — someone who learns your Member's priorities, remembers what you tried two years ago, and is still there to say so.
Here is the test worth applying. When your new digital director starts in March, does your vendor show up to get them productive, or to sell them something? One of those is a partner carrying your institutional memory for you. The other is a line item.
It's the model we use. Alpine provides full-service program management for constituent outreach programs run with official funds, which means the audiences and the record of what works sit outside the office's staffing cycle. On the Senate program we've run longest, that structure supports fifteen-plus audiences at a 67.8 percent average open rate, roughly three times the industry average. It doesn't hold up because the office has more people. It holds up because the program doesn't depend on which people. We built the firm to be the kind of vendor we wanted when we were the ones sitting in those chairs.
Every office in the building knows their outreach could be better — not just what goes to the inbox, but what goes in the mail and what runs on a screen. Most have known it for years, and it hasn't changed. It was never a knowledge problem and it was never an effort problem. The program keeps resetting, and the reset gets built in at the beginning — in what nobody wrote down, and in who the office trusted to remember it.
That part is a decision, and it's cheaper to make now than to discover in two years.
If you're putting a communications operation together and you'd rather not build that reset into it, send us a note. We'll find twenty or thirty minutes to talk through what you're starting with and what it would take to make the program outlast the people running it.

